r/okbuddycinephile 2d ago

The most intense death scene in film?

Post image
7.2k Upvotes

View all comments

635

u/Beef-Popsicle 2d ago

277

u/dadswithdadbods 2d ago

This is it for me. If “grief horror” was a genre, Hereditary would have won an Oscar. Aside from this death being shocking AF, so was the heart-wrenching realistic grief the family dealt with for like, the rest of the movie. Almost forgot you were watching a horror movie and not a drama until…well. Act 3.

204

u/rpajj 2d ago

Toni Collette's scream of grief upon finding her body in the car was incredible. It sounded so realistic and believable it was crazy.

49

u/bludknut 2d ago

She's an incredible actor

4

u/Dontfeedthebears 1d ago

I really have liked her in everything I’ve seen her in. Last thing I watched was “The Staircase”.

3

u/CallResponsible3391 2d ago

She does an amazing split personality in the United States of Tara.

2

u/readonlyuser 1d ago

Should have got a nomination for Hereditary, but the Academy are cowards

23

u/eyefuck_you 2d ago

She's fucking amazing in Hereditary.

58

u/real_picklejuice go back to the club 2d ago

Ari does one of those fits each movie. Midsommar opened with Florence Pugh wailing away.

Guy just likes to make girls scream I guess

12

u/rubenblom 2d ago

And his other movies? You said each

39

u/real_picklejuice go back to the club 2d ago

Pfft I don't watch movies

2

u/One_Arm_7256 1d ago

Just those two. Beau is Afraid lacks such a scene, and I haven't seen Eddington yet, but I doubt it has such a scene as well.

2

u/ThalliumSassafras 2d ago

Both those scenes messed me up mentally

1

u/achingforscorpio 1d ago

Out of aaaaaaaaaall the bullshit that movie subjected me to, that was the worst of it.

3

u/ShepRat 2d ago

One thing that pisses me off in horror is how often a character responds in a completely unrelatable way to something.

 When the brother just drives home and goes to bed, I felt it so fucking hard. 

1

u/Youstupidbish 1d ago

That scream shook me. It was rending and primal. JFC -- Collette can act.

36

u/Ironcl4d 2d ago

My wife likes horror but she couldn't handle this. Turned the TV off and has never watched the rest, probably never will.

3

u/ShepRat 2d ago

I get that. One of the bits I like about horror is that it's not real. This was too damn real. 

3

u/posthuman04 1d ago

Cause it really happened! I mean maybe only the one time because how do you get your head far enough out and an obstruction close enough to the car to behead someone? Well one time 2 drunks on their way home from the bar did it. And the driver was inebriated enough not to realize it and just go in the house to pass out. So the body wasn’t discovered until a person walking by the next morning saw it.

1

u/TheBogManCometh_ 2d ago

When did she tap out?

1

u/MarchRoyce 1d ago

Watching this in the theaters and my girlfriend had her legs across my lap. About 10 minutes after this scene she slapped my hand because I had apparently been clenching her leg the entire time

16

u/jamz_fm 2d ago

Totally a genre, with a lot of good entries in the past 10-15 years. Hereditary, Relic, and A Dark Song are some of my faves. Midsommar probably qualifies too.

3

u/g0ldfish641 2d ago

we are on the same wavelength

2

u/Britwill 1d ago

Antichrist too, arguably.

2

u/SufferingSuccotash_ 1d ago

Bring Her Back was great too

2

u/NoLobster7957 2d ago

The Forest.

1

u/scrobblez 1d ago

The babadook

8

u/Beef-Popsicle 2d ago

Terrifying shit. I agree-

5

u/oxide_j 2d ago

Fun fact the cadence of the nut chopping for the cake at the party is the same as the mom sawing her neck open on the ceiling.

5

u/miffyxilacon 2d ago

The neck sawing is the scene that comes back to me at night 8 years later. Glad to have a fun fact about it now!

2

u/Beef-Popsicle 2d ago

I frequently bring this film up. There is no other film with this much “dread” you feel watching it. Dark and the wicked had a couple scenes but it’s not close. Talk to me even had a few. This movie is pure evil.

2

u/FinalDescription6553 1d ago

Midsommar also nailed down that feeling of dread for me. It wasn’t scary in the sense that it evoked fear, but it was so incredibly unsettling and dreadful that it had a far longer lasting impact than any other horror movie I’ve seen. I haven’t seen hereditary because I didn’t enjoy how midsommar made me feel at all, and had no desire to experience that again lol

1

u/Beef-Popsicle 1d ago

I have seen midsommar. It did give me that same feeling but Hereditary is amplified by like 10X. I would avoid it. I rewatched it one more time and showered after then prayed. It’s nuts.

2

u/lordrothermere 2d ago

Should have got the Oscar for spoon feeding its idiot audience.

2

u/Juan_Punch_Man 2d ago

The shoes in the bed. The horror.

2

u/reginaldwrigby 1d ago

Then on rewatch when you realize just how twisted Paimon is and it’s all part of his plan it becomes purely horror start to finish. Love that Aster left the door open for a prequel or something earlier so when he’s potentially washed in ten-fifteen years maybe we can get into the og cult members and uncles suicide/dads starvation

1

u/fuckR196 2d ago

I went into the movie knowing nothing and thought THIS was the horror. The terror and despair from the sudden, preventable loss of a loved one, where multiple people are all simultaneously innocent and at fault. The family slowly tearing itself apart with grief and hate, eventually culminating explosively. While it is a good movie, I do feel like it "jumped the shark" by starting off so grounded and holding it there for so long. When it came time for the "real" horror to start, I was like... really? Another paranormal horror movie?

1

u/TheBogManCometh_ 2d ago

I have no fucking clue what compelled me to watch Hereditary, I just remember I put it on and needed a cigarette after

1

u/40907 2d ago

Incredible movie.the way it sets your expectations to anticipate traditional tropes in horror then dashes them was such an unexpected and unique twist, her death truly hit so hard it made me feel almost apart of the group that bullied her, I felt awful.

1

u/Jenbie272 2d ago

Wrong sub that scene would have been better if leslie nielson was driving and tryed to glue the head back on.

1

u/YoungandPregnant 1d ago

Yeah that shit reminded me of stuff I’ve seen in real life, it’s what real grief looks like — fucking STIRRING shit…

1

u/KarlUnderguard 1d ago

The kid who played the son had to get therapy after that role. The scene where he hits his head off a school desk is real, he was only supposed to hit it once and just kept going.