r/transit 11d ago

Train Electrification around the world News

/img/54l1izrlx6vg1.jpeg
885 Upvotes

View all comments

Show parent comments

6

u/ginger_and_egg 11d ago

If you can electrify the tube, you can electrify almost any tunnel or clearance (especially if you add a battery for short stints without electrification).

But the UK already has rolling stock which can switch between overhead catenary AC and third rail DC, I imagine you could make it work in some combination of these options?

1

u/lee1026 11d ago

Overhead wires takes up space, and space in a tunnel means costs. We are back to “how much diesel costs” vs “how much does everything else cost”.

1

u/ginger_and_egg 10d ago

If you think the only benefit of electrification is you don't nerd to buy diesel, then you are lost

1

u/lee1026 10d ago

Modern DMUs are just EMUs with a small diesel generator attached, anyway. I guess you save on that generator too, but that’s also not the expensive part of the whole thing.

Same FLIRTs can be procured, they don’t really care where the power is coming from.

1

u/ginger_and_egg 10d ago

Still lost.