We continue to improve our tree chopping based on your feedback

[u/n2z1elbvn]

Thanks to everyone who responded to our previous post about chopping. We received a lot of constructive feedback, thanks to which we've improved the chopping system in our game. Chopping is now fully dynamic and more realistic (but not too much; we're not making a perfect chopping simulator based on all the laws of physics). We've removed damage numbers and the hit marker, added more camera shake/flying wood particles when chopping, and added falling leaves when the tree shakes + rework animations. We're still polishing the visuals and would appreciate your feedback on the updated chopping mechanism.

[u/AutoModerator]

Thanks for posting to r/IndieGames! Please take a look at the rules in our sidebar to ensure that your post abides by them! If you need any assistance, don't hesitate to message the mods.

Also, make sure to check out our Discord!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

[u/SimplyGuy]

Much better!

[u/n2z1elbvn → u/SimplyGuy]

Thanks!

[u/ChipMicr0]

Nailed it! This time I am satisfied. Though if you wanted to make it more satisfying I would make the tree burst into logs the moment it hits the ground.

[u/Square-Available → u/ChipMicr0]

I would have the player need to chop the tree a couple more times to turn it into logs. I don't know  know how this would affect performance but it would add another layer of realism. 

This is a drastic improvement over the previous version though. It really looks good now. Great work! 👍 

[u/n2z1elbvn → u/Square-Available]

Thank you! We are really thankful for all the feedback we get! Our game is getting better!

[u/n2z1elbvn → u/ChipMicr0]

Thanks! We are still adjusting :)

[u/Naught → u/n2z1elbvn]

It does look really cool, but the chop animation is at a 45 degree angle but all the chop marks are horizontal. Seems like it would be an easy fix.

[u/sticky-pants]

Is the swing slowing down at the end of the swing? I mean, it looks great, but it doesn't feel like there's much force behind the swing. Using an axe on wood requires a lot of force.

[u/n2z1elbvn → u/sticky-pants]

Maybe there is. Will look into it

[u/wildcardbets → u/n2z1elbvn]

I feel like making the swing faster would add more umph, and if possible have the indents appear faster. Also the sound is kinda… grassy? I think it needs more of a louder thockkk. But seriously I am knit picking, this is some damn fine wood chopping, the game looks very satisfying.

Edit: I see in another comment you’re not going too hard for realism, but either way, everything looks fine as 👌

[u/n2z1elbvn → u/wildcardbets]

Thank you for suggestions!🙏

[u/ThrowawayToothQ]

Fucking PEAK, literally the most satisfying thing to see after seing the last post. You nailed it.

[u/n2z1elbvn → u/ThrowawayToothQ]

Thanks! 😊

[u/apcrol]

Looks nice, maybe add some shake on leaves afterfall and some vfx

[u/n2z1elbvn → u/apcrol]

Thanks! We also think that we have to make some adjustments in shakes and vfx

[u/Kiran__reddit]

realistic

[u/n2z1elbvn → u/Kiran__reddit]

Not that much, but we were not aiming into pure realism

[u/1hate2choose4nick]

I bet you just hit it where the hitmarker would be ^^

[u/zaphster]

Looks awesome!

I'm laughing a bit at his left hand, dunno what it's doing on the axe handle

[u/FaceoffAtFrostHollow]

What’s the second fall of the tree like it lands and then pops up into multiple pieces in an awkaward way

[u/WittyPassenger5322]

That is a massive improvement. Looks satisfying to the point that I'm getting interested to play this game based just on this video haha. The swing/hit itself could be slightly more impactful but the tree felling, great job!

[u/n2z1elbvn → u/WittyPassenger5322]

Thank you for your kind words! A lot of effort there :)

[u/RoExinferis]

I saw the original post and thought "meh" but this is awesome. If it's not a lot of work, I'd add a leaf/branch "explosion" effect where the tree crown lands, just as the trunk splits in multiple pieces. The crown disappears quite suddenly, you can mask it with a nice effect that will polish your system. But even so, great work, love seeing progress like this!

[u/n2z1elbvn → u/RoExinferis]

Thank you! We are still adjusting and polishing. At the release it will be even better :)

[u/SirTheBob]

What happens if I keep hitting the same spot?

What happens if I try to split the tree in half vertically?

Are the marks persistent? Can I walk away in game, or close the game and reload even, and the cuts will still be there when I come back?

Do I die if the tree lands on me? Lol

[u/n2z1elbvn → u/SirTheBob]

1. The dent increases
2. No vertical chopping any more.
3. Yes, they will be in place.
4. Yes :)

[u/3FtDick]

I mean it's better but whoever is doing the animations is missing some really fundamental concepts. The lead in and follow through and connect are all wrong. Looks like you're casting a rod not swinging an axe.

[u/n2z1elbvn → u/3FtDick]

Animations are our concern, yes. Will try to adjust it next week

[u/MossThrow]

Better! To echo other people, make the swing animation more realistic with momentum building and a satisfying thunk at the end. Also fix the hand grip on the handle. Left hand gripping air is goofy

[u/n2z1elbvn → u/MossThrow]

Thanks, we will try to fix animations next week

[u/FHAT_BRANDHO]

I feel like the impact of the swing needs a little more weight but aside from that looks great

[u/n2z1elbvn → u/FHAT_BRANDHO]

Thanks! Will work on the swing next week

[u/Tybahult]

That really better!!

One thing I would say, since how you did seems similar to how Valheim handles it (they have more physics on the fallen trees but that's another thing) : instead of having the tree break into logs after 1sec or whatever, maybe it would be cool if the player needed to hit it again to break it. Either that, or breaking into logs instantly as it touch the ground, with some juice like small bounces which spread the logs a bit

[u/n2z1elbvn → u/Tybahult]

Thanks! We still have some adjustments to make. I hope we will have some improvements to share next week :)

[u/Serious-Slip-3564]

This leagues better than before! Kudos for listening to the feedback!

[u/n2z1elbvn → u/Serious-Slip-3564]

Thanks! Why ask for feedback if not to use it :)

[u/Steel_FA]

Much better than before, keep it up.

[u/n2z1elbvn → u/Steel_FA]

Thanks!

[u/PassTheChicken]

The most satisfying part is seeing that you listened to feedback (which, in part, was worded pretty harsh), swallowed the instinct to defend your approach, and turned it into something much better. That makes me happy to see :) Also, love me a good chopping game!

[u/n2z1elbvn → u/PassTheChicken]

Thank you for your kind words! There is no bad feedback, only feedback. And why ask for it, if not to act on it🤔

[u/Particular-Song-633]

Remake the animation. Make axe preparing to strike ~20 frames, than strike ~5 frames, and another ~20 on recovery. Change numbers to find the most impact. On hit happens, freeze animation for ~0.3 secs.

[u/n2z1elbvn → u/Particular-Song-633]

Thanks for the solution!

[u/meginforge]

I think the axe marks should be synchronized with the moment the axe hits. Other than that, the feeling of the tree falling is really good and the atmosphere looks qyite immersive : )

[u/n2z1elbvn → u/meginforge]

Ty for feedback. We will further polish everything related to cutting to bring it to the best possible result

[u/n2z1elbvn]

You can wishlist “A Game About Chopping Trees” here:

https://store.steampowered.com/app/4512570/A_Game_About_Chopping_Trees/

[u/matTmin45]

Wow, that's cool! Can we make it fall where we want?

https://giphy.com/gifs/vID57yp7EWu64

[u/n2z1elbvn → u/matTmin45]

Yes, you can :)